Skip to main content
High-Yield Savings Account Comparison

American Express vs. EverBank

American Express' High Yield Savings Account advertises 3.20% APY while EverBank's Performance Savings lists 4.20% APY.

See how they compare on rate stability, mobile app ratings, and more below.

Analysis by Aviel Fahl
Newest reading November 19, 2026

The Bottom Line

On a $10,000 balance, EverBank's Performance Savings earns about $100 more in a year than American Express's High Yield Savings Account: $420 against $320.

Choose EverBank if getting the best rate matters most, BBB rating matters to you, or you value in-person banking and live in CA, FL, MO or NY.

Comparison of American Express vs EverBank savings accounts
Metric

American Express

High Yield Savings Account

Nov 19, 2026

EverBank

Performance Savings

Nov 19, 2026
APY3.20%4.20%
Earns in a year
$5,000+$160
$10,000+$320
$25,000+$800
$5,000+$210
$10,000+$420
$25,000+$1,050
Min. Deposit
$0$0

Snapshot view. Rates subject to change.

Features
FDIC InsuredNo MinimumsGreat iOS AppGreat Android AppZelle® SupportedDaily CompoundingRate Changes Often
FDIC InsuredNo MinimumsGreat iOS AppGreat Android AppIn-Person AccessZelle® SupportedDaily CompoundingStable Rate

Comparison Analysis

Comparing American Express vs. EverBank

Newest reading:

Executive Summary

American Express moved after 7 days, and EverBank moved after 16 days. EverBank leads with a standard rate of 4.2% on its Performance Savings account. It has not changed its rate since at least January 21, 2026. American Express paid 3.21% on average on savings and money market deposits. Its savings account offers a standard rate of 3.2%.

The analysis is based on current Banksparency database records

* This content is provided for informational purposes only; always verify details with the provider.

Why American Express?

No distinct advantages found vs EverBank.

Why EverBank?

  • Higher potential APY (4.20% vs 3.20%) on all balances
  • Physical branch access (11 locations in Florida and California), for Performance Savings only in CA, FL, MO and NY

Key Feature Differences

Better Returns at $10,000
EverBank

EverBank's Performance Savings earns more on smaller deposits (approx. $420 vs $320/yr).

Better Returns at $25,000
EverBank

EverBank's Performance Savings pulls ahead with larger amounts (approx. $1050 vs $800/yr).

Better for Simplicity
EverBank

EverBank's Performance Savings offers 4.20% APY with no bundling, direct deposit requirement or caps.

Shared Benefits

Both offer monthly maintenance-free account options Both banks have options with $0 opening deposit Fast transfers via Zelle® Available Nationwide Available to New & Existing Customers
The Bottom Line on APY (Interest Only)

Over a 1-year period, EverBank's Performance Savings pays $100 more interest on a $10,000 balance than American Express's High Yield Savings Account.

*This calculation assumes current rates remain consistent for 1 year and does not include temporary bonuses.

American ExpressEverBank
Verify at American Express

Non-sponsored link to official site

Verify at EverBank

Non-sponsored link to official site

Top Market Contenders

American Express vs. EverBank Savings Calculator

Calculations based on current APY for High Yield Savings Account and Performance Savings
$
$

You earn $100 more with EverBank than American Express on a $10,000 initial deposit for 1 year*.

*This calculation assumes that APYs remain unchanged for 1 year, and takes into account known promo rate periods, but does not factor in bonuses. You can see how often these banks have changed their rates in the Compare Savings Rates Over Time section below.

American Express

High Yield Savings Account

3.20% APY

Savings Breakdown

  • Interest Earned
    +$320.00(3.1%)
  • Total Contributions
    $0
  • Initial Deposit
    $10,000

Projected Balance

$10,320.00

Effective APY
3.20%

EverBank

Performance Savings

4.20% APY

Savings Breakdown

  • Interest Earned
    +$420.00(4.0%)
  • Total Contributions
    $0
  • Initial Deposit
    $10,000

Projected Balance

$10,420.00

Effective APY
4.20%

The Banksparency Savings Calculator provides estimated savings growth based on user input and our latest data.

Still at a large branch bank?

A typical branch-bank savings rate is 0.05% APY. On a $10,000 balance, the gap to these two banks is at least $315 a year in interest.

Both American Express and EverBank advertise far more than that typical branch-bank rate.

0.05% APY at a typical branch bank, against 3.20%+ here
See the highest rates
FeatureAmerican ExpressEverBank
APY
3.20%
Observed: 11/19/2026
0.20%90-day change
4.20%
Observed: 11/19/2026
0.30%90-day change
Product NameHigh Yield Savings AccountPerformance Savings
Minimum Deposit$0$0
Min. Balance for APY$0$0
Monthly Fee$0$0
Compound FrequencyDailyDaily
BranchesNoneOnly in CA, FL, MO and NY
Physical BranchesNone that serve this account43 (CA, FL, MO, NY)
Direct Deposit Req.NoneNone
Linked AccountNoNo
Mobile Apps
iOS4.9
Android4.8
iOS4.8
Android4.7
FDIC or NCUA Insured
Zelle® Support
Available
Requires Amex Rewards Checking; not available for standalone HYSA.
Available
Native integration verified.
BBB RatingFA+
Next Steps
Visit Site

Non-sponsored link to official site

Visit Site

Non-sponsored link to official site

What each bank pays on deposits

An advertised rate tells you what a new savings account earns today. It cannot tell you how the bank has priced the savings and money market deposits it already holds, over time. This section shows that. The figure is computed from the interest expense and deposit balances that every bank files with the FDIC in the same form. That is what makes it comparable across banks and across quarters.

American Express

3.21%
Q2 2026 ·
3.20% APY
As observed Nov 19, 2026

The two figures answer different questions, so they sit side by side and are not combined.

In Q2 2026, American Express paid a higher average rate on savings and money market deposits than 96% of banks that reported a figure (3,938 banks; FDIC call report). The all-bank median was 1.45%.

3.25%
Q2 2026 ·
$171.6B
Total deposits
Q2 2026
0.2%
Q2 2026

What American Express actually pays

Each figure is that bank's own charter-level average across its whole deposit book, so the two are shown one after the other and are not a ranking.

EverBank

3.32%
Q2 2026 ·
4.20% APY
As observed Nov 19, 2026

The two figures answer different questions, so they sit side by side and are not combined.

In Q2 2026, EverBank paid a higher average rate on savings and money market deposits than 97% of banks that reported a figure (3,938 banks; FDIC call report). The all-bank median was 1.45%.

3.15%
Q2 2026 ·
$37.8B
Total deposits
Q2 2026
5.4%
Q2 2026

What EverBank actually pays

Average annualized rates paid on savings and money market deposits, and on all interest-bearing deposits, quarterly. The FDIC line for savings includes money market deposit accounts and business savings deposits and does not separate consumer accounts. Source: FDIC call report data, as reported; it may be amended. The compares all FDIC filers, count-weighted. A missing quarter is suppressed, never interpolated. The percentile counts the banks that paid strictly less on savings and money market deposits, one vote per bank, among the 3,938 banks that reported a figure for the quarter ending June 30, 2026.

CD rates, term by term

American Express lists CDs on Banksparency at 10, 11, 12, 14, 18, 22, 24, 36, 48 and 60 months. EverBank lists CDs at 3, 6, 7, 9, 12, 13, 18, 24, 25, 30, 36, 48 and 60 months. Each row below is one term, with the best rate each bank advertises for it.

TermAmerican Express EverBank APYFDIC average (Nov 2026)
12 months3.75% APYNo minimum3.50% APY$1,000 minimum1.81%
3 monthsNot listed here3.60% APY$1,000 minimum1.14%
6 monthsNot listed here3.60% APY$1,000 minimum1.40%
7 monthsNot listed here3.60% APY$1,000 minimum1.40%6-month average
9 monthsNot listed here3.40% APY$1,000 minimum
10 months4.50% APYNo minimumNot listed here
11 months3.75% APYNo minimumNot listed here1.81%12-month average
13 monthsNot listed here4.30% APY$1,000 minimum1.81%12-month average
14 months3.75% APYNo minimumNot listed here
18 months3.75% APYNo minimum3.40% APY$1,000 minimum
22 months4.50% APYNo minimumNot listed here
24 months3.75% APYNo minimum4.50% APY$1,000 minimum1.60%
25 monthsNot listed here3.65% APY$1,000 minimum1.60%24-month average
30 monthsNot listed here3.40% APY$1,000 minimum
36 months3.75% APYNo minimum3.40% APY$1,000 minimum1.42%
48 months3.75% APYNo minimum3.40% APY$1,000 minimum1.33%
60 months4.50% APYNo minimum3.40% APY$1,000 minimum1.44%

Rates are annual percentage yields (APY). A variable rate may change after the account is opened. Fees could reduce the earnings on the account. A penalty may be imposed for early withdrawal.

FDIC national averages

Compare Savings Rates Over Time

Historical Performance

Last 12 Months Analysis
MetricAmerican ExpressEverBank
High Yield Savings AccountPerformance Savings
Current APY
3.20%4.20%
Trend
Stable Stable
Speed of change
-0.030.01
Days Since Change
3548
12-Month High
3.50%4.20%
12-Month Low
3.00%3.90%
Changes per month
0.580.16
Steadiness
0.0280.021

More Comparisons

Compare American Express' APY of 3.20% with other banks
Compare EverBank's APY of 4.20% with other banks