E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley vs. Valley Direct
Compare rates, requirements, and features side-by-side to find the best option for you.
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley
Premium Savings Account
3.75%APYDec 10, 2025FDIC InsuredNo MinimumsGreat iOS AppGreat Android AppShow Fine Print & Trends Hide Details
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley
Premium Savings Account
Valley Direct
High-Yield Savings Account
Up to4.10%APYDec 10, 2025FDIC InsuredLow MinimumsGreat iOS AppGreat Android AppRange: 3.50% – 4.10%Show Fine Print & Trends Hide Details
Valley Direct
High-Yield Savings Account
Market Reality Check
Both of these banks offer rates below the current top tier. The best rates we track are currently above 4.25% APY.
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley vs. Valley Direct Savings Calculator
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley earns $116.8 more than Valley Direct.
E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley
Premium Savings Account
Savings Breakdown
- Interest Earned+$2,273.80(11.2%)
- Total Contributions$13,000
- Initial Deposit$5,000
Projected Balance
$20,273.80
Valley Direct
High-Yield Savings Account
Promo Rate: 4.10% for 12 months, then 3.50%.
Savings Breakdown
- Interest Earned+$2,157.00(10.7%)
- Total Contributions$13,000
- Initial Deposit$5,000
Projected Balance
$20,157.00
The Banksparency Savings Calculator provides estimated savings growth based on user input and our latest data.
Comparison Analysis
Comparing E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley vs. Valley Direct
Why E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley?
- ✓Available to New & Existing Customers
Why Valley Direct?
- ✓Higher potential APY (4.10% vs 3.75%) on all balances
— Key Feature Differences —
Better Returns at $10,000
Valley DirectValley Direct's High-Yield Savings Account earns more on smaller deposits (approx. $410 vs $375/yr).
Better Returns at $25,000
Valley DirectValley Direct's High-Yield Savings Account pulls ahead with larger amounts (approx. $1025 vs $938/yr).
Best for Simplicity
Valley DirectValley Direct's High-Yield Savings Account offers 4.10% APY with no bundling, direct deposit requirement or caps.
Shared Benefits
Over a 1-year period (factoring in a 12-month promo), Valley Direct's High-Yield Savings Account pays $35 more interest on a $10,000 balance than E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley's Premium Savings Account.
*Valley Direct's calculation includes their 12-month introductory promotional rate and subsequent standard rate.
Executive Summary
Valley Direct offers a High-Yield Savings Account with a competitive APY of 4.10%, making it the winner compared to E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley's Premium Savings Account, which has an APY of 3.75%. Both accounts are online-only and feature no maintenance fees, but Valley Direct's account is available only to new customers for the advertised rate; existing customers receive a lower APY of 3.50%. E*TRADE's account has no minimum deposit or balance requirements, while Valley Direct requires a minimum deposit of $1,000. Overall, Valley Direct provides better returns, especially for larger deposits.
Analysis generated based on current Banksparency database records
* AI-generated content provided for informational purposes only. Accuracy is not guaranteed; always verify details with the provider.
Top Market Contenders
See who beats both E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley and Valley Direct.
| Feature | E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley | Valley Direct |
|---|---|---|
| APY | 3.75% Verified: 12/10/2025 ↘︎ 0.25%90d Change | 4.10% Range: 3.50% - 4.10% Verified: 12/10/2025 ↘︎ 0.20%90d Change |
| Product Name | Premium Savings Account | High-Yield Savings Account |
| Minimum Deposit | $0 | $1,000 |
| Min. Balance for APY | $0+ | $0.01 |
| Monthly Fee | $0 | $0 |
| Branch Access | None | None |
| Account Type | Online Only | Online Only |
| Direct Deposit Req. | None | None |
| Checking Bundle | No | No |
| Mobile Apps | iOS4.7 Android4.7 | iOS4.8 Android4.5 |
| BBB Rating | D- | A+ |
| Important Notes | - | Promo rate for new customers. 3.50% APY applies to existing customers. |
| Next Steps |
📈 Compare Savings Rates Over Time
Historical Performance
| Metric | E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley | Valley Direct |
|---|---|---|
| Premium Savings Account | High-Yield Savings Account | |
Current APY | 3.75% | 4.10% |
Trend | Stable | Stable |
Velocity (bps/mo) | -3.2 | -0.9 |
Days Since Change | 78 | 75 |
10-Month High | 4.00% | 4.40% |
10-Month Low | 3.75% | 3.75% |
Adjustments / Mo | 0.10 | 0.70 |
Volatility Score | 0.030 | 0.034 |
How to read these metrics(Click to expand)
Compare Similar High-Yield Accounts
Compare E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley vs...
Comparing against Standard Savings
Compare Valley Direct vs...
Comparing against Standard Savings
Higher Rates (With Checking)
Looking for something different? Check out these top-rated alternatives.